INDEPENDENT OPINIONS. EXTREMELY DEPENDENT ON BEER.EST. 2026 ✳ NO STUDIO NOTES.
WHAT THEDITKA✳
← All reviews

Phillip Marlowe sits down for a drink with his new client and the obligatory femme fatale, Claire Cavandash. Her husband approaches and, not wanting to admit she has hired a private eye to search for her missing lover, she rips the necklace from her neck and passes it to Marlowe in the hopes of selling the story that she’s hired him to recover some jewelry that was misplaced.

Her brooding husband who lives in a state of perpetual suspicion sees through it and tells them both to piss off.

As he storms off Claire says to Marlowe “I don’t think he fell for it Mr. Marlowe. Maybe he thinks we’re involved. Involved in something sexual.”

And right there is what’s wrong with Marlowe and what plagues it through much of the film. This was 1940 and crass banter like that wouldn’t have been common in private, let alone out loud at an exclusive country club in LA.

The sentence the writer wanted, or should have wanted, was “Perhaps he thinks were involved. Involved in something TORRID.”

You can’t write a film noir movie set in the late 30’s or early 40’s and give the characters modern sensibilities and dialogue choices. It’s jarring. It pulls you out of the moment and out of the time period you’re trying to absorb.

Here’s another one. Marlowe loses his gun and turns to an old cop buddy to replace it. His pal pulls one out of a drawer and says “Here this is your .38. You never had another one. Hey if they ever start tracking serial numbers we’re screwed.”

Now why add that last bit? Because someone thought the audience was so stupid we didn’t realize they didn’t have nationwide firearm data bases in 1940. The writers looked us dead in the eye and said “Hey stupid, this scene actually is believable because this is how it worked 80 years ago. Just wanted to make sure you knew that because you’re a little dense.”

Throughout this movie all the required ingredients for a film noir exist. Plenty of red herrings, dastardly blonde bombshells, villains with bizarrely resplendent vocabularies, guys slamming whiskies at 2 PM and heading back to work, hard boiled detectives, complacent cops and complicit wealthy dirtbags, all the delicious side stories from the underbelly of 1940 LA. It’s all there. But it’s like someone bought the most extravagant ingredients and, rather than give them to a great chef, handed them to a home cook trying to make a Tik ToK video. All the great stuff that went into the oven came out barely edible.

Some of the dialogue is so clunky entire characters seem like imitations of imitations. They knew the literal definition of film noir but they didn’t really understand it. What snappy dialogue does exist comes out of some very interesting characters but it gets lost because there’s so many characters none of them really get developed. Colm Meany is great in this but good luck finding him. Blink and he’s gone.

And this is tough for me because I love Liam Neeson. And the thing here is that agreeing to even play Marlowe takes balls. It’s like the American Idol contestant who insists on singing Whitney Houston-no matter how good her voice she’s just, well, she’s just not Whitney. And Neeson is great as usual but he’s not Bogart and when you follow in Bogarts shoes, you really don’t stand a chance.

Another issue I have is the way it was shot. Yeah the cinematographer got it all technically right. Gentle sepia tones, neon lights reflected in puddles and fog, harsh yellow office lighting. All that is there. But from the very first minute of the movie I couldn’t stop thinking “This should have been shot in black and white.” Yeah I get that would be the obvious way to shoot it, but that’s what makes it brave.

On the plus side it was awesome to see Jessica Lange turn up after what seems like an enternity. She’s as talented as she ever was and steals the scenes consistently from her younger counterparts. Hollywood “aged” her out years ago and sadly what could have been a brief bounce back is probably going to fizzle out as this things a commercial and critical dumpster fire.

Still, there’s enough here that if you’re nostalgic for a Marlowe, or even a Mike Hammer story that you’ve never experienced you might have some fun with it. It’s a solid D effort but given movies in this style are exceedingly rare it’s a “well it’s better than nothing” situation if you like noir.

Share on Facebook

WHAT THE DITKA