INDEPENDENT OPINIONS. EXTREMELY DEPENDENT ON BEER.EST. 2026 ✳ NO STUDIO NOTES.
WHAT THEDITKA✳
← All reviews

The Watchers. Or as the complete title should read: The Watchers, brought to you by pointless nepotism.

Ishana Shaymalan, daughter of the once venerated M. Night, writes and directs her first feature film with this one. She inherited her father’s penchant for atmosphere, I’ll give her that. But the similarities end about there.

It feels like someone who learned at the knees of her father and now truly wants to emulate the old man, but just isn’t quite there yet. Tried to run before she could walk. A magician who attempted The Great Escape but she hadn’t yet mastered the rabbit from the hat trick.

There’s something here. She really was onto something, but she didn’t quite get there. An attempt was made at the now Generational Shaymalan twist, but I saw it coming ten miles away and you will as well.

Unlike her father who, with Signs, taught us that with monsters or aliens sometimes less is more, the daughter decided to go another way. She let the cat out of the bag too soon. Spent a lot of time building up the mystique and letting your mind fill in the blanks and then pulled back the curtain just a little before she should have.

I think the word to describe it is safe. It felt to me like she wanted to take some risks but couldn’t bring herself to do it. Like that guy who gets a muscle car and tells everyone he’s gonna “open it up” and then stomps on the gas. But as the needle climbs he becomes increasingly nervous and right about when speeding is just going to slip into straight speed, he backs off. When 79 mph was about to turn into a true rocket ride, pulls his foot off the gas and watches the speed drop back to a less risky 65. Satisfied to live with the thrill of what he almost did. A moment he will revisit when he’s 60 years old, telling his buddies he should’ve just done it. “I almost did. I was so close,” he’ll say.

And that’s what’s this feels like. A brand new filmmaker who decided she needed to deliver something that will do mediocre box office numbers. It won’t really disappoint anyone. But it won’t thrill anyone either. It’s just a straight down the middle pitch.

But she wanted to take some chances. You can feel it. I don’t know if she was afraid to and have a flip her first time out, or if someone talked her out of it and told her to play it a little safe. Or maybe, alternatively, she was trying so hard to make a movie that wouldn’t have people making direct comparisons to her dad that she just lost the mark entirely.

It’s filled with somewhat iffy dialogue and riddled with random snippets of exposition that seem to come from nowhere. As though she watched a rough cut and said “We should know a little more about that person” and so she shoe-horned in a few lines of dialogue to flesh something out.

It’s not the worst thing I’ve ever seen by any stretch. And there’s enough there to make me believe a film or two from now when she’s no longer afraid to really drop the hammer and be herself, that she can do something special. This isn’t it.

But it is the movie you’ll remember ten years from now when you walk out of something she did that was remarkable. You’ll think back to her start and realize how far she’s come. It’s worth seeing just for that.

One final word: Dakota Fanning didn’t do her any favors. They apparently didn’t have coffee in those woods because man, she sleeps walks through a decent amount of this. Not her finest hour.

Share on Facebook

WHAT THE DITKA