
Sing Sing
4 out of 5 Ditkas
Imagine, if you will, that you’re at a funeral. You’re standing in a line of mourners waiting to approach the casket, one step at a time forward.
You look down at your feet and there’s a nervous energy to you because you know that you’re a few shuffles of your feet away from seeing something you don’t want to. Something that’s going to make you incredibly sad. Something inevitable. It can not be changed. This is going to happen.
When you finally arrive it’s as bad as you feared. You stare down at the deceased and a sorrow, deep and soul-blackening, permeates your very being. Suffocating. Inescapable.
At that very moment, when you’re drowning in it and can’t take anymore. When you want to avert your eyes but you can’t. Right then, the guy next to you spits out a one-liner. Something the deceased once said in life that was uproariously funny.
You can’t help yourself. A smirk twinges just at the corners of your mouth. And then you fully remember that moment and you laugh.
Your laughter feels refreshing and necessary. It feels like salvation right at the moment you were about to sink under the water. It was a life preserver you desperately needed. But it also feels a little wrong. A little inappropriate. Some old lady off in the corner gives you a stern look. How can you be laughing at a time like this?
That moment, right there exactly, is where this movie lives.
And it’s what it wants to tell you. It wants you to know, it needs you to know, that’s what the human spirit is. That you can find a tiny, tiny slice of laughter and joy inside a huge pie of sorrow.
And some people wake up day after day after day and they are served a huge pie of sorrow and despair but get, they always find that time slice of something else. Something better.
So much of this movie drips with hopelessness and despair that when it makes you chuckle, and it will, it feels so needed and yet…wrong. Because we know there’s another pie of despair waiting for these characters right around the corner.
There’s a struggle going on for the souls of these men right in front of you. And it’s visceral. You can feel it.
The dialogue is so crisp and genuine that you really, with your very soul, root for their redemption.
And so many times this movie gave me a scenario or a character that made me think “Well I know what he’s going to do. Ah, there’s the villian of the story I’ve seen that character before.”
And I was wrong. Every single time I was wrong. It never once ventured into recycled characters. Never once did it reuse a plot contrivance I’ve seen previously. It surprised, saddened, delighted and then surprised again.
If Colman Domingo is not nominated for best actor the Academy should be disbanded. I mean, it should be anyway, it’s been useless and irrelevant for some time now. But as long as they insist on handing out awards, this man should get one.
You could spend an entire same semester with a very gifted and brilliant professor of literature and you’d never stop finding new layers to this. New meanings to conversation you at first thought innocuous.
You could pull apart every single line of dialogue and you’d never tire of analyzing it. Because every single line is impactful. Nothing is wasted and all of it is brilliant.
This movie is powerful. You never see me say that because I absolutely believe that, by the literal definition of the word powerful, few things are. There are very few movies, plays or pieces of music that can truly, in an honest way, live up to that label.
If you asked me to and I had a few hours I could muster up ten movies that I thought we’re powerful in a literal sense. Now, tonight, I could muster up 11.
Now look, this isn’t going to be for everyone. And I’ll once more beg James Murynec to skip this one. He won’t because despite my protestations he insist on seeing films we’re destined to argue about.
Sing Sing had a film festival release a year ago a year ago. Toronto and a few of the others. So it’s been in the can a while. Not sure why.
But to me, were I in charge, it’s a clear best picture winner. And it’s going to take something in the next few months, something once-in-a-lifetime remarkable to change my mind on that.