INDEPENDENT OPINIONS. EXTREMELY DEPENDENT ON BEER.EST. 2026 ✳ NO STUDIO NOTES.
WHAT THEDITKA✳
← All reviews

Imaginary, ironically, seems totally devoid of imagination. Ostensibly a haunted doll type story it rather quickly devolves into a haunted imaginary friend story. Either way, you’ve seen it before plenty of times.

All the tropes are there. Like all of them.

Old lady who lives down the street. She knows what’s really going on but no one believes her and the neighborhood considers her just a nut. They eschew her advice and admonitions until it’s too late. Check.

Dead mother leading to two damaged and angry children who constantly, and sometimes shockingly, have endless conflict with a stepmother. Check.

Recalcitrant and obnoxious teenager who hates everyone, but stepmom the most, but in the end turns out to be a misunderstood little darling. Check.

I could go on. I wouldn’t be even a little surprised if, in the years to come, someone admitted an AI wrote this. It feels for all the world like someone asked a computer to scare me and, having no real concept of what fear is, it just scoured the Internet for scary tropes and spit them out.

I firmly believe I could have made this movie myself by splicing together scenes that I found in 100 other movies and not much about it would substantively change.

And while I’ve read a dozen reviews savaging this, and rightfully so, what I haven’t seen mentioned is what I thought to be some pretty direct Alice in Wonderland allusions (rip offs).

One of the films greatest sins comes at the hands of the older daughter. She clearly has a knack for snark, comedic timing and caustic sarcasm but they don’t let her find her voice until the closing moments. It left you thinking “Where was THIS girl 90 minutes ago” because if they had taken the time to develop her character just a little bit past cartoonish teenager they may have had something. It’s a mystery they didn’t solve until about 15 minutes remained in the movie and it was like watching a 70 yard touchdown pass bounce out of the receivers hands. So close.

In the end it’s not even meh, it’s just bad.

Share on Facebook

WHAT THE DITKA